Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

For the love of the money or the game?

Published: Monday, December 12, 2011

Updated: Tuesday, December 13, 2011 17:12

 With all the superstar commotion over the past week, we should thank God that ESPN isn't stacked with a December "Decision" marathon featuring 1 hour specials with the likes of Dwight Howard, Chris Paul and Albert Pujols announce the next club they will be playing for.

In lieu of Pujols inking a 10-year $254 million deal with the Angels, CP3's vetoed trade to the Lakers and Superman formally requesting the Magic for a change of setting, we have to wonder: are these athlete soap operas a trend that's doomed to continue?

LeBron James set a precedent with his "Decision" two summers ago, opting to leave his home state of Ohio to pursue a championship in Miami. Arguably the most talented player in the NBA and by far the most marketed, his choice to leave the Cavaliers and team up with Chris Bosh and Dwayne Wade set an example for other stars around the league. LeBron proved to the world that he would do whatever it took to win, even it meant leaving the place where he was loved and adorned the most by some of the most dedicated hard luck fans on the planet in Cleveland.

So did Lebron make the right decision? Well, the Heat got to the NBA finals in his first year with the team coming up just short to the Mavs in six games, faring much better than he ever did in his seven years with the Cavaliers. If his goal was truly to solely win an NBA championship, he certainly is in one of the best places to do just that: Win a championship for the city of Miami.

That last sentence might have thrown you off a bit. I don't think LeBron thought about it that way either. Perhaps he was too caught up worrying about winning a ring for himself than he was realizing what it means to a team, organization and community to hoist a Larry O'Brien Trophy. LeBron's whole decision, the process, the means, and the ends can all be summarized with one simple word: selfish.

And that, ladies and gentlemen, is how we can describe these trials of our modern day athletes. Are they playing for themselves, the money, the stardom, the fame, or are they playing for the communities that come out to support them night in and night out, their drive to see the success of everyone around them and most importantly, their love for the game.

Pujols ‘decision was one that came down to dollars and cents. Reminiscent of A-Rod's record deal with the Texas Rangers (who were at the time a perennial loser in the American League) ultimately is was more important for Pujols to sign for more cash (the Cardinals offered him $224 million for 10 years to the Angels $254) than finish his career with the team he spent the first 11 years of his career with, won two World Series rings in a St. Louis community where his name is held at the same stature as Stan Musial.

Paul however is in a stickier situation. He plays in an organization that is a complete mess. The Hornets have no true owner, a sporadic fan base and have David Stern to overcome when it comes to personnel moves. To the media's knowledge, Paul has not come out and openly requested to be traded, but his departure seems inevitable as he approaches the final year of his contract. There's nothing really for Paul to be loyal to in New Orleans and the team as is isn't good enough to contend for a championship, so it would be absurd to think he would consider resigning with the Hornets this offseason.

Howard's request to the Magic to be traded reminds me all too much of LeBron. It was just four years ago when he signed his contract extension and joked that he and Mickey Mouse would remain in Orlando for forever. Two years removed from a NBA finals sweep and an early exit from the playoffs last year, D12 wants out. After year's trades and signings to give the Magic the best shot at winning, he wants out. In an organization completely dedicated to winning a championship with a team built around him, he still wants out. That's a lot of work to implode, Dwight.

In all, athletes should have the right to make these decisions for themselves. Like LeBron remises in his "What Should I Do?" commercial, they aren't going to be who we want them to be. Lebron, Dwight, Pujols, CP3, Carmelo Anthony, A-Rod, Deron Williams, they are entitled to make the decisions that are best for themselves.

But just because we give these athletes the right to make their own choices on where they go doesn't mean we have to agree with them. LeBron will always be hated by a portion of the basketball community and will continue to be exposed by his until he stops having an identity crisis on the court and defers the ball to Wade down the stretch, like he did in Games 5 and 6 of the NBA Finals. (You are selfish LeBron, stop trying to convince the world that you aren't.)

It might be undermining the fabric of perfect competition in the NBA to watch players hop on large market teams to chase championships (Why is there no franchise tag Stern? Did you all do anything but complain during the lockout?), and watch the team with the deepest pockets stack their team in baseball every year (I don't even want to get in to the fact how disgusting it is that the MLB has no salary cap), but at the end of the day, athletes are mature adults just trying to successful just like anyone else. It's up to them to decide what they want to do, not us.

 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

7 comments

Anonymous
Thu Dec 15 2011 18:04
Lol, the star is one of the worst student newspapers on the planet, so spending this much time writing on an anonymous comment thread puts you way beneath that awful piece of drat.
He's Right
Thu Dec 15 2011 16:38
Obviously Matt Hines got a 'savvy sports expertise' with this awful article. I pretty much can't disagree with anything from Anonymous. No need for the name calling though come on guys you really going to get that heated over some comments from amateur article from the Sonoma State Star?
what a faggot
Thu Dec 15 2011 16:34
`you have` parkinsons ` or somet`hing ``````
What a loser
Thu Dec 15 2011 13:35
`I'm sure your Sonoma State education gives you a savvy sports expertise.
Anonymous
Thu Dec 15 2011 00:09
Your just ignorant and pissed at life sorry Lebron made a lot more out of himself than you ever will. I'm a student at Sonoma State by the way what do you mean I must work for Nike that doesn't even make sense. Do I work for Adidas too since I back Dwight? What about Jordan Brand since I think it's cool Melo gets to play back in his hometown? And that CP3 is in LA not on the Lakers but with Griffin and his boy DJ. Different people want different things if you want to spend you life making other people happy good for you go ahead and do that. Sucks that you don't get to live life through yourself and be who you want but hey if your a people pleaser go for it. Have fun being someone's b!^@h where ever you work.
haha
Wed Dec 14 2011 22:47
Lol this guy must work for nike
Anonymous
Wed Dec 14 2011 18:45
CP3 demanded a trade, "The word is that the agent for Chris Paul(notes), Leon Rose, has called his employer, the New Orleans Hornets, and informed the team that his client isn't going to take a contract extension and would like the team to just go ahead and trade him to the New York Knicks." -Mark Miller Yahoo! Sports. The Orlando Magic wouldn't make the playoffs in the west if they didn't have Dwight. Since they are in the terrible east and teams like the 76ers and Pacers make the playoffs unfortunately Orlando will. Every organization is dedicated and wants to win a championship. Orlando's efforts to build a team around Dwight is atrocious, Rashard Lewis and Gilbert Arenas just to name a few. I would want out too if the organization I played for said they would get players around me to help me win but failed as bad as the Magic. You don't need much when you have the best center the league has seen since Shaq in his prime. It is a tragedy that the Magic have not won a title actually.
Lebron selfish really? Taking a pay cut to play with two really close friends of his is selfish? To get out of the city he has lived in his whole life and experience something new is selfish? To have an opportunity to live in Miami in what most consider the best years of your life is selfish? I don't see it man. Sit back and think, if you were offered a job in any city in the US and you got to choose would Cleveland, Ohio even come to mind? Why would Lebron live his life to make everyone else happy? He has needs too, he is a human being with desires. He has brought something great to South Beach and created a great community. He was going to do that anywhere he went and he knew it. You are wrong in so many ways its awful you think that. To call him selfish in game too is idiotic. He could go down as better than Michael Jordan when everything is all set and done, and trust me I hate saying that Michael is my hero. Kobe is considered one of the most clutch if not the most clutch player in NBA history (I don't agree). How clutch was he early on in his career? Not at all (If you need proof let me know). Lebron is young and he is actually pretty clutch despite what everyone thinks and is still getting better at the end of games (again if you need proof let me know). If your so pissed about this blame professional sports for not having something in place to stop this from happening because it happens in every sport on every level. Is the Fab 5 selfish for teaming up at Michigan? If so every athlete that has been recruited is selfish because they usually pick a team that has the best chance of winning or joining friends/family somewhere. Lebron did join Miami to win championships not just for himself but to do it with friends in a place that had opened their arms and heart to him. In what better fashion can you win an NBA championship. I know that's how I would want to do it, with my best friends right at my side in a place that appreciates everything I've done. Not saying Miami was the only place he could do that but it certainly made the most sense.






log out